Upfront Installation: Metal Shingles vs Asphalt Shingles Cost
Metal shingles vs asphalt shingles cost is one of the most common questions homeowners face when replacing a roof — and the answer depends on whether you’re thinking short-term or long-term.
Here’s a quick comparison to answer the core question:
| Asphalt Shingles | Metal Shingles | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost (installed) | $4,000 – $25,000 | $18,000 – $75,000 |
| Cost per sq. ft. | $3.50 – $8.50 | $9 – $30 |
| Lifespan | 15 – 30 years | 40 – 70+ years |
| Replacements over 50 years | 2 – 3 times | 0 – 1 time |
| Repair cost per incident | $300 – $1,000 | $800 – $2,500 |
| Energy savings | Minimal | Up to 25 – 40% cooling reduction |
| Recyclability | Limited | Fully recyclable |
Bottom line: Asphalt costs less upfront. Metal costs less over a lifetime.
Asphalt shingles win on day one. Metal shingles win over the next 50 years. The right choice comes down to your budget, how long you plan to stay in your home, and what kind of weather your roof has to handle — especially here in New England.
I’m Tom Gordon, owner of Twin Metals, Inc. and Twin Roofing, and with nearly two decades of installing both asphalt and metal roofing systems across Massachusetts and New Hampshire, I’ve seen how metal shingles vs asphalt shingles cost plays out in the real world — not just on a spreadsheet. In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to make a confident, informed decision.
When we talk about the initial “sticker shock,” there is no denying that asphalt is the more budget-friendly entry point. Most homeowners in Massachusetts and Southern New Hampshire opt for Residential Shingle Roofing because it is familiar and affordable.
However, when you look at Residential Metal Roofing, you are essentially pre-paying for decades of protection. The material prices for metal are significantly higher because of the manufacturing process and the quality of the alloys used (like steel, aluminum, or copper).
Labor complexity also plays a massive role. Installing asphalt is like a high-speed puzzle; a skilled crew can often finish a standard home in a day or two using basic utility knives and nail guns. Metal shingles, on the other hand, require specialized cutting tools, specific fasteners, and a much higher level of technical training.
How Roof Complexity Impacts Metal Shingles vs Asphalt Shingles Cost
Not all roofs are created equal. If you have a simple “up and over” gable roof, your costs will stay on the lower end of the spectrum. But New England is famous for its beautiful, complex architecture. Factors that drive up the price include:
- Roof Pitch: Steeper roofs require extra safety equipment and more time for installers to move around.
- Dormers and Valleys: Every time the roof changes direction, we have to use more flashing and custom-cut materials.
- Waste Factor: Complex roofs lead to more material “scrap.” While asphalt waste is just heavy trash, metal scrap is expensive, though we do recycle it!
For those managing larger properties or business spaces, Commercial Metal Roofs often face these same complexity issues but on a much larger scale.
Average Pricing Ranges Based on Internet Data
It is important to note that the following figures are average costs based on publicly available internet data, not our specific company pricing. Every home in towns like Andover, MA or Nashua, NH is unique, and local labor rates can shift.
- Asphalt Shingle Installation: $5,000 – $25,000+
- Metal Shingle Installation: $18,000 – $75,000+
Why such a wide range? A 1,200-square-foot ranch will obviously cost less than a 4,000-square-foot colonial. Additionally, market fluctuations in steel and petroleum (used in asphalt) can change these numbers month-to-month.
| Material Type | Estimated Cost Per Square Foot (Installed) |
|---|---|
| Basic 3-Tab Asphalt | $3.50 – $6.00 |
| Architectural Asphalt | $5.00 – $10.00 |
| Stone-Coated Metal | $9.00 – $18.00 |
| Standing Seam Metal | $12.00 – $30.00 |
Long-Term Value and Expected Lifespan
If you plan on living in your home for the next 30 to 50 years, the math starts to favor metal very quickly. According to a 2024 Cost Comparison: Metal Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles, a metal roof can last two to four times longer than its asphalt counterpart.
We often tell our clients in places like Concord or Chelmsford that an asphalt roof is a “20-year solution.” Even the best architectural shingles usually start showing their age after two decades of New England winters. By year 50, you will likely have paid for three separate asphalt roofs. A single metal roof, installed correctly, should still be going strong.
For property owners looking at Commercial Shingle Roofing, this lifecycle is even more critical because the disruption of a replacement can affect business operations.
Material Durability and Environmental Impact
Durability isn’t just about how long the roof stays on; it’s about how it handles “The Big One”—that massive hailstorm or nor’easter. Metal shingles are famously tough. In fact, some manufacturers have tested their metal shingles with ice cannons, and they barely dented.
From an environmental standpoint, the contrast is even sharper.
- Asphalt: Roughly 11 million tons of asphalt shingles end up in landfills every year. In many parts of the Northeast, there are no local recycling facilities for them, meaning they sit in the ground for 300+ years.
- Metal: Most metal roofs contain 25-40% recycled content and are 100% recyclable at the end of their life.
As noted by NerdWallet, metal also reflects solar heat, whereas asphalt acts like a sponge, soaking up the sun’s rays and heating up your attic.
Maintenance and Repair Cost Differences
Every roof needs a little love now and then. For Residential Roofing, we recommend a quick check-up every few years.
- Asphalt Maintenance: You’ll need to watch for grit loss (those little pebbles in your gutters), moss growth, and shingles that might curl or blow off in high winds. Repairs are usually cheap ($300–$1,000) because the materials are easy to swap out.
- Metal Maintenance: Metal is virtually maintenance-free. You might need to check the fasteners or clear some debris from the valleys, but you won’t be dealing with rot or insect damage. However, if a tree limb falls and punctures a panel, the repair is more technical and costly ($800–$2,500).
ROI, Energy Savings, and Insurance Benefits
Can a roof actually pay you back? In some ways, yes. While the metal shingles vs asphalt shingles cost is higher for metal at the start, the Return on Investment (ROI) is impressive. Metal roofs can recoup up to 85% of their cost in home resale value, compared to about 60-70% for asphalt.
If you are a business owner, Commercial Roofing investments in metal can also offer significant tax advantages and long-term operational savings.
Insurance Discounts and Fire Ratings
Insurance companies love metal roofs. Why? Because they don’t burn and they don’t fly away. Most metal roofing qualifies for a Class A fire rating (the highest possible) and exceptional impact resistance. In hail-prone areas or regions with high wind risks, many insurers offer premium reductions of 15% to 30%. It’s always worth a call to your agent in MA or NH to see what kind of “metal discount” they offer.
Energy Efficiency and “Cool Roof” Technology
In the heat of a Massachusetts July, your AC is working overtime. Metal shingles are considered “cool roofs” because they reflect solar reflectance and have high thermal emittance. Instead of your attic reaching 150 degrees, a metal roof keeps things much cooler. Some homeowners report a 25% to 40% reduction in cooling costs after switching from dark asphalt to a reflective metal system.
Frequently Asked Questions about Metal Shingles vs Asphalt Shingles Cost
Is metal roofing noisier than asphalt during rain?
This is the number one myth we hear! If you were standing in an old barn with a single sheet of tin over your head, yes, it would be loud. But on a modern home, we install solid roof decking, high-quality underlayment, and thick attic insulation. These layers act as a sound barrier. In most cases, you won’t notice any difference in noise levels between metal and asphalt.
Can metal shingles be installed over existing asphalt?
In many cases, yes! This is called a “re-roof.” It can save you thousands of dollars in labor and disposal fees because we don’t have to tear off the old shingles. However, this depends on your local building codes in towns like Woburn or Peabody and the structural integrity of your roof frame. We always check the weight limits before recommending this.
Which roofing material is better for New England winters?
Both have their perks, but metal has a slight edge for snow management. Metal shingles allow snow to slide off more easily, which prevents the heavy weight loads that can stress a house frame. It also helps prevent ice dams—the arch-nemesis of every New England homeowner. Asphalt shingles, because they are textured and stay warmer, tend to hold onto snow longer, which can lead to ice buildup if your attic isn’t perfectly vented.
Conclusion
Choosing between metal and asphalt isn’t just about the price tag today; it’s about the value you want for your home over the next few decades. At Twin Metals Roofing, we take pride in providing superior performance and quality materials regardless of which path you choose. Whether you are looking for the tried-and-true affordability of Residential Shingle Roofing or the “forever” protection of a metal system, we are here to help.
If you’re ready to see what the actual metal shingles vs asphalt shingles cost would be for your specific home, we invite you to reach out for a professional consultation. We serve homeowners throughout the region with a commitment to exceptional customer service and craftsmanship that lasts.
Explore our full range of Residential Roofing services to find the perfect fit for your property.
The company services Berkshire County in Eastern Massachusetts and Southern New Hampshire.
Follow us on Facebook — https://www.facebook.com/twinmetalsroofing Follow us on Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/twinmetals/
